It’s officially the end of an era for former Philadelphia Eagles head coach Andy Reid with a devastating record of 4-12 for the 2012 regular season. Eagles owner Jeff Lurie stood by his word as he bid Andy Reid farewell after an 8-8 record for the 2011 season. For those fans clamoring that we should not have let Andy Reid go since he was the Eagles franchise most successful coach to date, the Eagles organization is still a business. And if Jeff Lurie kept Andy Reid for another season as a coach or otherwise, Lurie would be made to be nothing more than a paper tiger at best and a pushover at worst. In as much as some of us criticize Washington Redskins owner Dan Snyder for being a pushover, Jeff Lurie would made to look much worse.
Andy Reid became head coach of the Philadelphia Eagles on January 11, 1999. It was not without criticism upon arrival in Philadelphia after he was lured from the Green Bay Packers. In 2000, the Philadelphia Eagles reached the playoffs with a 11-5 regular season record. In 2001, the chain of playoff wins came. With quarterback Donovan McNabb, running back Brian Westbrook and safety Brian Dawkins coming to maturity, the Philadelphia Eagles was the team to beat in the NFC East with conference championships in 2001, 2002, 2003 and 2004. In 2004, with the acquisition of wide receiver Terrell Owens, the Eagles were at this time the cream of the crop of the NFC East and decisively the NFL. The Eagles made it to Super Bowl XXXIX but was ultimately defeated by Tom Brady and his New England Patriots 24-21. Donovan McNabb simply cracked under pressure in this Super Bowl, and with the Eagles essentially without a functioning quarterback, the New England Patriots won.
After the stream of successes prior to 2004, the wheels of the truck began to fall off in 2005 as the disputes between Terrell Owens, Donovan McNabb and David Akers tore apart the team in the locker room. In 2005, the Eagles ended with a regular season record of 6-10. In 2006, with the season-ending injury to Donovan McNabb in October, backup quarterback Jeff Garcia took over the reigns and nearly led the Eagles to another Super Bowl after defeating the Carolina Panthers, the New York Giants and the Washington Redskins. However, as Jeff Garcia led them closer and closer to the Super Bowl, Donovan McNabb came out of the woodwork and became disruptive from the sidelines in a sense. This antagonism ultimately led to Jeff Garcia being released — and Donovan McNabb as well.
In 2008, the Eagles made their way to the NFC Championship game whereupon they lost to the Cardinals 32-25. The Eagles traded Donovan McNabb to the Washington Redskins in 2009, and after McNabb’s departure, then backup quarterback Michael Vick was named starting quarterback in 2010. Vick’s most notable game as a Philadelphia Eagle was the decimation of Donovan McNabb and his Washington Redskins on the night of November 15, 2010. On that night, Michael Vick was unleashed as he had four passing touchdowns and two rushing touchdowns with a passer rating of 150.7.
After Michael Vick’s spectacular run in 2010, the wheels began falling off the truck again. Most teamis had developed a gameplan for Vick’s weaknesses and tendencies as the New York Giants and the Dallas Cowboys both built sufficient defense gameplan templates the season before. The other teams in the NFL basically followed suit, adjusting their templates as needed. And with Michael Vick not holding much better himself in the 2011 and 2012 regular seasons, the Philadelphia Eagles demise was gradual and climaxed in this regular season with compounding losses with ridiculous amount of turnovers.
With the loss of defensive coordinator Jim Johnson on July 28, 2009, the Philadelphia Eagles defense never was the same. Sean McDermott took over, but he could never build the Eagles defense as Jim Johnson could. Soon, even he was released to the Carolina Panthers on January 5, 2011. And with the acquisition of Nnamdi Asomugha and Dominque Rodgers-Cromartie in the 2011 season, it seemed like a recipe for success. Perhaps under the traditional defense of Jim Johnson. With Juan Castillo and his implementation of the Wide-Nine defense, the defense collapsed unto itself as there were no leaders, only highly-paid players.
Andy Reid should be remembered for the successes he bought to the Philadelphia Eagles organization. With few notable candidates currently to fill the void, 2012 Maxwell Coach of the Year Penn State’s Bill O’Brien seems to be the leading candidate. Quite possibly, in my opinion, the former Chicago Bears Lovie Smith would be a potential option as well. In either case, the options are not particularly tempting. Reid went over his head with the promotion of Juan Castillo as a defensive coordinator, the firing of Sean McDermott and the wholesale acquisition of free agents. These are perhaps what did him in as a head coach. Most likely, he will be acquired by the Arizona Cardinals as Ken Whisenhunt was recently fired. A change of scenery will do him good. Will it bring him as much success with the Philadelphia Eagles? Perhaps, but I remain skeptical.
- Donovan McNabb defends Andy Reid’s legacy (bleedinggreennation.com)
- McNabb: Eagles fans now see winning not easy (espn.go.com)
- Andy Reid never measured up without Donovan McNabb (philly.sbnation.com)
- Andy Reid fired as head coach of the Eagles (nj.com)
- Eagles Announce End Of Reid’s Tenure (philadelphiaeagles.com)
- Eagles Fire Andy Reid After 14 Seasons (abcnews.go.com)